Home / Chroniques / Is the future of space tourism doomed by its environmental cost?
Orbital Vacation, Imagine a futuristic scenario where space tourism is commonplace
Généré par l'IA / Generated using AI
π Society π Planet

Is the future of space tourism doomed by its environmental cost?

GraphiqueCollé‑1
Olivier Berné
Astrophysicist and CNRS Research Director at Institut de Recherche en Astrophysique et Planétologie (IRAP)
Key takeaways
  • On 28th April 2001, the first space tourist, Dennis Tito, took off for a week-long stay in space, becoming the first space tourist.
  • Yet, 25 years on, there have not been tens of thousands of space tourists, but only around 140.
  • Moreover, space tourism cannot develop without addressing the elephant in the room: the environmental cost.
  • In terms of energy consumption, one hour of space flight is equivalent to at least 400 hours on an aeroplane.
  • And if half of humanity were to take a space flight in a single year, the level of CO₂ in the atmosphere would increase by a factor of 2.8, leading to global warming of more than 4 degrees.

Twenty-five years ago, the first space tour­ist, Den­nis Tito, set off on a week-long trip into space, thereby becom­ing the first space tour­ist. Since then, the sec­tor has not really taken off, and envir­on­ment­al con­cerns have made it extremely unpop­u­lar with the gen­er­al pub­lic. Des­pite this, some still hope to make it a viable ven­ture, includ­ing in France.

On 28th April 2001, the Amer­ic­an busi­ness­man Den­nis Tito boarded a Soy­uz cap­sule to travel to the Inter­na­tion­al Space Sta­tion (ISS) on a jour­ney last­ing around a week. What made this flight unique was that the bil­lion­aire was not an astro­naut but simply a space tour­ist. A world first for which Tito had shelled out some 20 mil­lion dollars1, a sig­ni­fic­ant fin­an­cial wind­fall at the time for the space sec­tor, which was seek­ing to turn a profit. Bet­ter still: for some, it her­al­ded the dawn of a new era. A world in which tak­ing a ride on a rock­et and then vis­it­ing a space sta­tion in orbit would be just as com­mon­place as going for a hot-air bal­loon ride or sky­diving. Den­nis Tito predicted 2 that tens of thou­sands of people could enjoy such an exper­i­ence, at a cost rep­res­ent­ing 5 or 10% of what he had had to pay.

And yet, 25 years on, there have not been tens of thou­sands of space tour­ists. Only around 140, accord­ing to the latest figures 3, wheth­er for orbit­al flights alone or for stays on board the ISS. Fur­ther­more, prices have not fallen dra­mat­ic­ally as prom­ised, giv­en that Blue Ori­gin was offer­ing seats for $28 mil­lion in 2021. Oth­er com­pan­ies, such as Vir­gin Galactic, are aim­ing for a price of $750,000 for a trip into orbit, but the set­backs exper­i­enced by its spacecraft 4 do little to inspire confidence.

Space tech­no­logy can be used to doc­u­ment glob­al warm­ing, observe the Uni­verse, or to foster a broad­er per­spect­ive on the world. Tour­ism should be the low­est of pri­or­it­ies, far behind all of that.

“Space tour­ism has always been based on a prom­ise,” says Olivi­er Berné, an astro­phys­i­cist at IRAP (Insti­tute for Research in Astro­phys­ics and Plan­et­o­logy). “It is noth­ing more than a pipe dream that has gen­er­ated fun­drais­ing and fuelled fin­an­cial spec­u­la­tion, which does not guar­an­tee it a future.” In France, how­ever, the BPI (Pub­lic Invest­ment Bank) still has high hopes5 for this sec­tor. Aware that the bulk of the action is tak­ing place across the Atlantic, the organ­isa­tion nev­er­the­less insists that Europe and France can carve out a place for them­selves in this sec­tor, par­tic­u­larly in pas­sen­ger train­ing, para­bol­ic flights and the­or­et­ic­al training.

Des­pite this optim­ism, the sec​tor’s future remains rather bleak. Firstly, instead of the pre­dicted fall in prices, one of the most com­pet­it­ive com­pan­ies in the field, SpaceX, has recently increased its rates6, rising from $6,000 to $7,000 per kilo­gramme of pay­load. For its part, Blue Ori­gin is tem­por­ar­ily step­ping back from the sec­tor to focus on oth­er areas, not­ably lun­ar mod­ules. Oth­er US “New Space” com­pan­ies, such as Axiom and Vast, are bank­ing on their future private orbit­al sta­tions, which will even­tu­ally be able to accom­mod­ate tour­ists. But this will not hap­pen until, at the earli­est, the 2030s, and at a price that has yet to be determined.

That being said, the devel­op­ment of space tour­ism can­not pro­ceed without address­ing the ele­phant in the room: the envir­on­ment­al cost. It is not uncom­mon for the space sec­tor to be cri­ti­cised for the pol­lu­tion it causes, even by those who are an integ­ral part of it. Olivi­er Berné, for instance, has been tasked with invest­ig­at­ing the pol­lu­tion caused by the work of astro­phys­i­cists. How­ever, whilst the green­house gases emit­ted by research­ers’ work or rock­et launches can some­times be jus­ti­fied by the sci­entif­ic bene­fits they yield, the same can­not be said for this tour­ism sector.

This view does not pre­vent some in the industry from believ­ing that reusable launch vehicles and new gen­er­a­tions of fuel could reduce the envir­on­ment­al cost. But this techno-solu­tion­ist vis­ion clashes with real­ity, accord­ing to Paul Peeters, a trans­port and envir­on­ment spe­cial­ist at the Uni­ver­sity of Breda in the Neth­er­lands. “Even if rock­ets were to become more effi­cient, it’s com­pletely illus­ory,” he asserts. “They would need to be 99 % more effi­cient and eco­nom­ic­al for space tour­ism to be envir­on­ment­ally sus­tain­able. Per­haps this will be achieved one day, but cer­tainly not in the short or even medi­um term.”

The research­er has worked on this issue on sev­er­al occa­sions, and in a 2018 study7, he explains in detail why space tour­ism can nev­er be com­pat­ible with envir­on­ment­al pro­tec­tion, unlike oth­er, more envir­on­ment­ally friendly prac­tices. “In terms of energy used, one hour of space flight is equi­val­ent to at least 400 hours on an aero­plane. We simply do not have enough energy on Earth for space tour­ism to become a mass phe­nomen­on. That is an enorm­ous num­ber of resources spent solely for the pleas­ure of a few people.”

To veri­fy this, the research­er scru­tin­ised sev­er­al cli­mate mod­els to estim­ate the envir­on­ment­al impact of such activ­it­ies. He also applied this data to mod­els relat­ing to plan­et­ary bound­ar­ies, par­tic­u­larly in terms of resources. Taken togeth­er, this data shows just how illus­ory it is to think that space tour­ism can be scaled up. Accord­ing to this data, if half of human­ity were to take a space flight with­in a year, the level of CO₂ in the atmo­sphere would increase by a factor of 2.8; this would lead to glob­al warm­ing of more than 4 degrees, a fig­ure found in the IPCC’s most pess­im­ist­ic scenarios.

Paul Peeters adds that these lim­it­a­tions are not due to any kind of envir­on­ment­al act­iv­ism, but simply to the laws of phys­ics: “A cer­tain amount of energy is required to send humans into space, and we can­not reduce that. Fur­ther­more, no real reg­u­la­tions have been put in place to pre­vent com­pan­ies from enter­ing this sec­tor. If it does​n’t take off, it will be for tech­nic­al reas­ons, not because of an envir­on­ment­al roadblock.”

Whilst tak­ing this envir­on­ment­al dimen­sion into account may con­trib­ute to mak­ing the space tour­ism sec­tor unpop­u­lar, it is not neces­sar­ily what would have held it back. But behind these rather dis­cour­aging fig­ures, com­pan­ies spe­cial­ising in the sec­tor have found oth­er oppor­tun­it­ies. This is the case, for example, with Vast, which has​n’t ruled out selling places on its future orbit­al sta­tion to tour­ists, but which, in the mean­time, is sign­ing con­tracts with NASA and CNES to send European astro­nauts into space, not­ably Thomas Pes­quet in the near future, fol­lowed by Arnaud Prost.

“There are sci­entif­ic aspects to these mis­sions, but they’re only there to make the pill easi­er to swal­low,” explains Olivi­er Berné. “From this per­spect­ive, with the increas­ing privat­isa­tion of space, the main thing is to have some­thing to sell. These are new prom­ises that sus­tain a sec­tor which bene­fits only a select few, without seek­ing the pub­lic interest. If the aim were truly to pro­mote sci­ence, there would be many oth­er things to do first.”

Admit­tedly, bil­lion­aire space tour­ism in the style of Den­nis Tito seems set to remain a rare phe­nomen­on reserved for a select few. But manned space­flight in the broad­er sense is sub­ject to the laws of the private sec­tor, with mis­sions that must, above all, be eco­nom­ic­ally prof­it­able for com­pan­ies. Sci­entif­ic bene­fits take a back seat.

Hugo Ruher
1https://​www​.ina​.fr/ina-eclaire-actu​/video​/cab01021188​/le-milliardaire-dennis-tito-dans-l-espace↑
2https://​lesas​delinfo​.com/ephemerides​/280​/28-avril-2001-premier-voyage-d-un-touriste-spatial↑
3https://​thecon​ver​sa​tion​.com/private-space-tourism-is-taking-off-but-laws-on-outer-space-are-from-another-era-283761↑
4https://​www​.franceinfo​.fr/content​/734003​/embed/↑
5https://​big​me​dia​.bpi​france​.fr/nos-dossiers​/tourisme-spatial-un-nouveau-marche-pour-leconomie-du-new-space↑
6https://​x​.com/AlexNajjarEC​/status​/2026235487523066130 ↑
7https://​www​.tand​fon​line​.com/doi​/abs​/10.1080​/02508281. 2018.1511942↑

Our world through the lens of science. Every week, in your inbox.

Get the newsletter