103_La liberté académique_
Home / Dossiers / Society / Knowledge under pressure: how far does academic freedom extend?
π Society

Knowledge under pressure: how far does academic freedom extend?

4 episodes
  • 1
    The birth of academic freedom in the United States
  • 2
    Academic freedom in decline in Europe and around the world
  • 3
    Should there be limits to academic freedom?
  • 4
    Academic freedom: where does France stand?
Épisode 1/4
On June 11th, 2026
3 min reading time
Hervé DUMEZ
Hervé Dumez
Emeritus CNRS Research Director and Professor at Ecole Polytechnique (IP Paris)

Key takeaways

  • Academic freedom emerged in the United States at the turn of the 20th century with the Edward Ross case and his stance on Chinese immigration.
  • The American Association of University Professors (AAUP) drafted the landmark declaration, which consists of three dimensions: freedom of research, freedom of teaching, and freedom of expression outside the university.
  • This declaration also specifies that a researcher may be judged only by his or her peers, and not by administrative superiors.
  • Between 1950 and 1960, amid the Red Scare, the Supreme Court ruled in 1957 in the case of Sweezy v. New Hampshire, affirming that imposing restrictions on university intellectuals would jeopardize the very future of the country.
  • Academic freedom thus remains a living right, constantly negotiated among researchers, institutions, the state, and society.
Épisode 2/4
On September 22nd, 2026
3 min reading time
Angelo Vito Panaro_VF
Angelo Vito Panaro
Postdoctoral Researcher at the Institute of Political Science at Friedrich-Alexander University

Key takeaways

  • Between 2015 and 2025, as many as 50 countries recorded a substantial, statistically significant decline in their academic freedom index.
  • In the United States, the Florida governor’s signing of the Stop WOKE Act in 2022 contributed to this decline.
  • According to the Balme report, a significant portion of the world’s outstanding scientific output originates in environments where academic autonomy is subject to systemic and existential constraints.
  • In Europe, the situation is deteriorating, but academic freedom is still better protected there than elsewhere.
  • Universities with a high degree of autonomy are better equipped to resist external pressures.
 
Épisode 3/4
On June 17th, 2026
3 min reading time
Eric Guilyardi_VF
Éric Guilyardi
Climatologist, CNRS Research Director and Member of the Pierre-Simon Laplace Institute

Key takeaways

  • Scientists must constantly assess the risk-benefit balance of research topics in light of societal values.
  • Geoengineering encompasses techniques aimed at artificially modifying the climate to reduce global temperatures, at the risk of disrupting local water cycles.
  • Some research projects stem from industrial strategies, such as tobacco companies that funded ‘distraction’ research into other risk factors for lung cancer.
  • The lack of public funding alone does not explain researchers’ interest in industrial projects, as governments continue to provide substantial support for basic and climate research.
Épisode 4/4
On October 21st, 2026
6 min reading time
Olivier Beaud_VF
Olivier Beaud
Professor of Public Law at Université Paris-Panthéon-Assas

Key takeaways

  • There is no consensus on the definition of “academic freedom” in France.
  • In France, abusive legal proceedings take the form of SLAPP suits, which are not intended to win the case but to intimidate or hinder a person’s actions.
  • A “climate of suspicion” reportedly weighs particularly heavily on researchers speaking out “on contemporary issues related to Israel.”
  • According to Olivier Beaud, French universities are not truly autonomous, as they are under the financial control of the state and weighed down by bureaucracy.