Home / Chroniques / “Controlled inflation will help to boost growth”
π Economics

“Controlled inflation will help to boost growth”

Jean-Baptiste Michau
Jean-Baptiste Michau
Professor of Economics at École Polytechnique - CREST (IP Paris)

Some eco­nom­ic play­ers are wor­ried about the return of infla­tion. Is this good or bad news, and are there grounds for such fears?

To under­stand infla­tion, it helps to look at Japan. For the past 25 years, the coun­try has had no infla­tion and slug­gish growth despite an ultra-expan­sion­ary mon­e­tary and fis­cal pol­i­cy. The mon­ey sup­ply issued by the Bank of Japan has increased ten­fold while pub­lic debt has reached 250% of GDP – more than dou­ble that of France! The sit­u­a­tion is total­ly para­dox­i­cal. And yet, it is worth noth­ing because since the finan­cial cri­sis of 2008 it the lack of infla­tion also con­cerns the euro zone and (to a less­er extent) the Unit­ed States.

This “sec­u­lar stag­na­tion” is explained by a per­sis­tent lack of demand due to demo­graph­ic age­ing. Peo­ple are sav­ing for their retire­ment, then for their health expens­es and final­ly to pass on to their chil­dren and grand­chil­dren. This is com­pound­ed by ris­ing inequal­i­ty, which con­cen­trates pur­chas­ing pow­er in the hands of the wealth­i­est peo­ple, who have high sav­ings rates, and by slow­ing pro­duc­tiv­i­ty gains, which encour­age house­holds that are more pes­simistic about the future to save more.

To coun­ter­act a decline in demand, cen­tral banks low­er their inter­est rates. This dis­cour­ages house­holds from sav­ing and encour­ages com­pa­nies to invest. But at the heart of the cur­rent prob­lem is that cen­tral banks have run out of ammu­ni­tion: inter­est rates can­not go below 0%. No finan­cial asset can have a return sig­nif­i­cant­ly low­er than that of mon­ey. Cen­tral banks can cre­ate mon­ey, but this has no macro­eco­nom­ic impact, since savers are hoard­ing. In these cir­cum­stances, con­trolled infla­tion is desir­able because it would stim­u­late demand.

Infla­tion is favourable right now because ris­ing prices melt the val­ue of sav­ings like snow in the sun.

Explain this to us.

Infla­tion is favourable right now because ris­ing prices melt the val­ue of sav­ings like snow in the sun. House­holds there­fore have an incen­tive to con­sume. They antic­i­pate high­er prices and buy goods before they become more expen­sive. The increase in con­sump­tion increas­es the need for labour by com­pa­nies, which gen­er­ates upward pres­sure on wages and prices. Infla­tion can become a self-ful­fill­ing prophecy.

Will we see a return of inflation?

In the Unit­ed States, it is pos­si­ble. Aging of the pop­u­la­tion is less pro­nounced than in Europe and fis­cal pol­i­cy is much more aggres­sive and strong­ly stim­u­lates demand. Before the pan­dem­ic, we were already see­ing infla­tion­ary pres­sures fuelled by Don­ald Trump’s expan­sion­ary fis­cal pol­i­cy, which allowed the US to reach full employ­ment: 3.5% unem­ploy­ment. The US fis­cal stim­u­lus has been sig­nif­i­cant­ly ampli­fied by the pan­dem­ic. Joe Biden is now com­mit­ting a stim­u­lus pack­age of $1,900 bil­lion, in addi­tion to the $900 bil­lion decid­ed last Decem­ber. This brings the total to $2,800 bil­lion, a stratos­pher­ic fig­ure that rep­re­sents 13% of GDP. The risk of infla­tion exists, but there is no con­sen­sus among econ­o­mists on this sub­ject. It will depend on the reac­tion of the Fed, the US cen­tral bank. But the US seems will­ing to take the risk of mod­er­ate infla­tion to avoid the lost decades seen in Japan.

Can infla­tion get out of hand?

We can­not elim­i­nate this pos­si­bil­i­ty, but the risk is under con­trol. The Fed has tools and can raise rates. And, if nec­es­sary, tax­es can be raised, for exam­ple through the intro­duc­tion of a val­ue-added tax (dif­fer­ent and much more fis­cal­ly pro­duc­tive than the cur­rent “sales tax”). This would curb demand and thus inflation. 

What about Europe?

There may be tem­po­rary infla­tion linked to recov­ery and bot­tle­necks in sup­ply chains. But the risk of sus­tained infla­tion is low in the euro­zone because the fis­cal stim­u­lus is mod­er­ate. The Euro­pean Commission’s stim­u­lus pack­age is lim­it­ed to €700 bil­lion, half of which is in loans, all spent over five years and spread across 27 coun­tries. In the Euro­zone, as is often the case, it is “too lit­tle, too late”. This is a pity because the pan­dem­ic is a unique oppor­tu­ni­ty to gen­er­ate a mas­sive fis­cal stim­u­lus and to get out of sec­u­lar stag­na­tion once and for all. Let’s remem­ber that the Unit­ed States only real­ly turned the page on the Great Depres­sion with a mas­sive fis­cal stim­u­lus: the Sec­ond World War. That said, the dif­fi­cul­ty of the sit­u­a­tion should not be under­es­ti­mat­ed. Despite a great deal of bold­ness, Japan has still not man­aged to return to growth and escape the liq­uid­i­ty trap.

Are there oth­er ways to stim­u­late demand?

There are sev­er­al avenues. For exam­ple, econ­o­mist Lar­ry Sum­mers sug­gests dis­cour­ag­ing sav­ings by strength­en­ing social pro­tec­tion with more redis­tri­b­u­tion, more gen­er­ous health insur­ance or by devel­op­ing pay-as-you-go pen­sions. In the Unit­ed States, this is a pos­si­ble way for­ward, but in France we have no room for manoeu­vre. Anoth­er solu­tion would be to replace paper mon­ey with elec­tron­ic mon­ey, which would allow neg­a­tive inter­est rates by tax­ing bank deposits. But that would not be very pop­u­lar… Infla­tion is a much more pain­less way to tax deposits!

Interview by Clément Boulle


Jean-Baptiste Michau

Jean-Baptiste Michau

Professor of Economics at École Polytechnique - CREST (IP Paris)

Jean-Baptiste Michau's research focuses on macroeconomics, labor economics and public finance. He has published "On the provision of insurance against research-induced wage fluctuations", Scandinavian Journal of Economics 2021, "Monetary and fiscal policy in a liquidity trap with inflation persistence", Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 2019, or "Optimal social security with imperfect marking" (with Oliver Denk), Scandinavian Journal of Economics 2018.

Our world explained with science. Every week, in your inbox.

Get the newsletter