Home / Chroniques / Poor mental health amongst healthcare workers: what nearly 35,000 calls to a helpline reveal
Defocused person offering warm mental health helpline support on a call, soft bokeh, caring listener background
Généré par l'IA / Generated using AI
π Society

Poor mental health amongst healthcare workers: what nearly 35,000 calls to a helpline reveal

Irène Georgescu_vf
Irène Georgescu
Professor of management sciences at Montpellier Management, Université de Montpellier
Etienne Minvielle
Etienne Minvielle
Director of the Centre de Recherche en Gestion at Ecole Polytechnique (IP Paris)
mpoypro
Jacky Mpoy
Statistical Engineer at CNRS and Member of the Interdisciplinary Institute for Innovation (IP Paris)
Key takeaways
  • Published in the journal Santé publique, the findings of a study of 35,000 calls to the national helpline for healthcare professionals, Soins aux professionnels de santé (SPS), unequivocally confirm the professional distress experienced by the medical profession.
  • This service comprises a 24-hour helpline, a mobile app, and more than 120 psychologists on hand, supported by a network of practitioners trained to identify burnout and psychosocial risks.
  • Of the 7,005 calls in 2024, 87% lasted more than one minute, and each call is categorised on a scale ranging from a simple administrative enquiry (stage 0) to an imminent risk of self-harm (stage 5).
  • Nearly a third of the calls indicated confirmed occupational burnout (stage 3) and nearly 30% indicated depression (stage 2).
  • In total, 609 sources of distress were identified and grouped into three categories: organisational, individual and environmental.
  • The first category accounts for 42.6% of all causes reported: chronic work overload, tension within teams, a feeling of not being recognised, a lack of institutional support and the growing burden of administrative tasks.

Burnout, dis­en­gage­ment, sui­cid­al thoughts… since the late 2010s, the occu­pa­tion­al dis­tress exper­i­enced by health­care work­ers has fea­tured increas­ingly prom­in­ently in pub­lic debate in France, although no pre­cise data is avail­able on its true scale or causes. Six years later, between 2016 and 2024, a nation­al psy­cho­lo­gic­al sup­port ser­vice ded­ic­ated to health­care work­ers, SPS (Soins aux pro­fes­sion­nels de santé), recor­ded almost 35,000 calls from these health­care pro­fes­sion­als. As the ser­vice was designed to be access­ible 24 hours a day, it has, over the years, accu­mu­lated a vast amount of data that has, until now, been largely untapped. These anonymised calls enabled our recent study, pub­lished in the journ­al Santé pub­lique1, to shed light on and provide an in-depth under­stand­ing of this dis­tress and well-being.

The ser­vice is simple in prin­ciple: a num­ber access­ible at any time, a mobile app, more than 120 psy­cho­lo­gists on hand to listen, and behind them, a whole net­work of prac­ti­tion­ers trained to identi­fy burnout and psychoso­cial risks. When it was set up in 2016, it received just 220 calls a year. Eight years later, in 2024, that fig­ure had increased more than thirty­fold, reach­ing 7,005 calls, an aver­age annu­al growth rate of 54%. The turn­ing point came between 2019 and 2020, dur­ing the very first months of the Cov­id-19 pan­dem­ic. But con­trary to what one might think, the trend did not level off once the health crisis had passed. It con­tin­ued to rise, nev­er return­ing to its pre­vi­ous level.

Does this mean that men­tal health dis­tress exper­i­enced by health­care work­ers has skyrock­eted by the same pro­por­tion? Not neces­sar­ily. Part of this increase is simply due to the fact that the ser­vice is now bet­ter known than it was when it first began. But it also reveals some­thing else, some­thing deep­er: health­care work­ers are increas­ingly will­ing to put their dis­tress into words, provided they are giv­en an anonym­ous space to do so. This is both an encour­aging sign, show­ing that people are speak­ing out, and con­firm­a­tion of a very real need that con­tin­ues to grow.

A sense of distress, predominantly among women

The fig­ures for 2024 give an indic­a­tion of what lies behind each phone call. Of the 7,005 calls recor­ded that year, 87% las­ted more than a minute. This sug­gests that the con­ver­sa­tions were more sub­stance-driv­en than mere ini­tial con­tact. Nearly three in ten of these longer calls took place at night, between 10pm and 8am, and one in sev­en on Sundays. These times speak volumes about the moments when dis­tress leads to a call and the import­ance of the ser­vice when the usu­al sup­port ser­vices have closed for the night.

Who are these callers? In sev­en out of ten cases, they are women, with an aver­age age of 34. Nurses form the largest iden­ti­fied group (14.4% of calls), fol­lowed by care assist­ants (9.3%) and doc­tors (7.9%). But the range is in fact much broad­er. Dent­ists, mid­wives, vets, health­care stu­dents… all health­care pro­fes­sions are rep­res­en­ted. Sev­en out of ten calls res­ult in a refer­ral for sup­port; around half lead to a face-to-face con­sulta­tion with a psy­cho­lo­gist; one in five to a doc­tor or psy­chi­at­rist; and 13% to human resources, a man­ager or occu­pa­tion­al health.

Each call is also clas­si­fied by the psy­cho­lo­gists on a sever­ity scale, from 0 (a simple admin­is­trat­ive enquiry) to 5 (an immin­ent risk of sui­cide). Nearly a third of the calls relate to con­firmed burnout (stage 3) and nearly 30% to depres­sion (stage 2). One fig­ure, in par­tic­u­lar, is worth not­ing: in 2024, 138 calls, 2.3% of the total, were related to sui­cid­al thoughts or an immin­ent risk of self-harm.

Behind these fig­ures are very con­crete real­it­ies: chron­ic work over­load, ten­sions with­in teams, a feel­ing of not being recognised…

Bey­ond the call stat­ist­ics, the core of the study is based on a qual­it­at­ive ana­lys­is of 330 inter­view tran­scripts. The research­ers iden­ti­fied 609 factors con­trib­ut­ing to dis­tress, which they grouped into three cat­egor­ies: organ­isa­tion­al, indi­vidu­al and envir­on­ment­al. The first cat­egory accoun­ted for the vast major­ity, at 42.4% of all causes iden­ti­fied over the entire study peri­od. This pro­por­tion is even set to rise fur­ther to 42.6% over the peri­od 2023–2025. Behind these fig­ures, very con­crete real­it­ies recur time and again: chron­ic work over­load, ten­sions with­in teams, a feel­ing of not being recog­nised, a lack of insti­tu­tion­al sup­port, and the grow­ing bur­den of admin­is­trat­ive tasks.

Indi­vidu­al factors account for 35.6% over the entire peri­od. These include isol­a­tion, job insec­ur­ity, sleep dis­orders and a grow­ing inab­il­ity to “switch off” from work. The most strik­ing aspect is the reveal­ing rise in these factors: they accoun­ted for just 8% of the causes cited in 2017, com­pared with 23% today. As for envir­on­ment­al factors, such as staff short­ages, aggres­sion from patients or their fam­il­ies, health crises, and rap­id and suc­cess­ive insti­tu­tion­al reforms, the fig­ures have also changed, rising from 3.7% in 2017 to nearly 15% in the recent peri­od. It is there­fore not a single, isol­ated cause that emerges from these inter­views, but a com­plex inter­play: in a grow­ing num­ber of cases, work over­load, a lack of sup­port and extern­al pres­sure are pil­ing up, without it always being pos­sible to identi­fy the root cause and its spe­cif­ic con­sequences. A snow­ball effect that drags health­care work­ers into mount­ing dif­fi­culties with a sig­ni­fic­ant impact on their well-being.

A widespread but uneven vulnerability

No health­care pro­fes­sion is exempt from this obser­va­tion. How­ever, two groups stand out. The first is well known from pre­vi­ous research: front­line health­care work­ers, those in daily con­tact with patients, are over-rep­res­en­ted amongst those who called. The second is more unex­pec­ted in terms of its scale: stu­dents and young pro­fes­sion­als form a par­tic­u­larly vul­ner­able group. Oth­er stud­ies cited in our work sug­gest that 52% of health­care stu­dents exhib­ited symp­toms of anxi­ety in 2024, and that 21% of them had already exper­i­enced sui­cid­al thoughts. In their accounts, a recur­ring pat­tern emerges: a pro­fes­sion­al com­mit­ment bor­der­ing on guilt, a fear of fail­ing to meet expect­a­tions they have come to inter­n­al­ise, and a dif­fi­culty in set­ting bound­ar­ies. These dynam­ics are also found amongst more exper­i­enced health­care work­ers, but are even more pro­nounced amongst young­er staff, who are often sim­ul­tan­eously faced with job insec­ur­ity and a lack of recognition.

In light of these find­ings, we advoc­ate for a response com­men­sur­ate with the diversity of the causes iden­ti­fied, one that com­bines indi­vidu­al sup­port with organ­isa­tion­al trans­form­a­tion with­in pub­lic health policies. Psy­cho­lo­gic­al sup­port remains essen­tial, but the pre­dom­in­ant role of organ­isa­tion­al determ­in­ants means that action must also be taken at man­age­ment level: rede­fin­ing mana­geri­al prac­tices, pla­cing great­er value on team­work, and pay­ing par­tic­u­lar atten­tion to hier­arch­ic­al rela­tion­ships with­in health­care set­tings. These are levers that involve both team lead­ers and the col­lect­ive func­tion­ing of the depart­ments themselves.

What listen­ing to these 35,000 calls reveals, by implic­a­tion, is a pro­found and wor­ry­ing trend in work­place dis­tress with­in the health­care sec­tor. This trend calls for a fun­da­ment­al rethink of the ways in which sup­port is provided, recog­ni­tion is giv­en and work is organ­ised with­in health­care set­tings. The chal­lenge is no longer lim­ited to the indi­vidu­al pre­ven­tion of dis­tress: it is now a mat­ter of bring­ing about a genu­ine trans­form­a­tion of the work­ing envir­on­ments in which health­care work­ers oper­ate on a daily basis.

1Georges­cu, I., Min­vi­elle, É., & M’Poy, J. (2026).“Analyse de la souf­france des soignants à tra­vers le dis­pos­i­tif SPS​.”Santé pub­lique, 38(2), 217–224.↑

Our world through the lens of science. Every week, in your inbox.

Get the newsletter